Ghosts of sacked Waratahs coaches starting to hover over Daryl Gibson

Daryl Gibson Nigel Owen/Action Plus via Getty Images

He's less than two years in the job, but Daryl Gibson has already discovered like many others that coaching the Waratahs can be the most confounding of occupations.

Still if his coaching record doesn't quickly improve he won't have to worry much longer about the trials of his job as he will go the way of many other failed Waratahs coaches- farewelled well before their supposed expiry date.

The Waratahs have got rid of their fair share of coaches including Chris Hawkins, Matt Williams, Ian 'Speed' Kennedy, Ewen McKenzie and Michael Foley. Those in charge at the Tahs know how to discard ineffectual leaders. Gibson is rapidly moving into that lame duck category as the Waratahs have begun 2017 exactly as they finished 2016- lacking focus, momentum, direction or a distinctive playing style.

Nothing new for Super Rugby's worst performers.

Despite enjoying the luxury of being perched in Australia's biggest rugby province, NSW Waratahs have in the 21-year history of the Super Rugby tournament been the biggest flops.

For a province that boasts easily the highest rugby participation numbers in Australia and based in a city that has intense top-end-of-town rugby links, to only boast one Super Rugby title (in 2014) is an embarrassment. Considering the supposed high calibre players they have boasted, lured and signed, one championship triumph in 21 years is pathetic.

They have been the masters of lost opportunities- and a lot of that is due to appalling off-field leadership, both in administration and the coaching ranks. No wonder the Waratahs head office has long been known as 'Fort Fumble.'

'Fort Fumble' has turned making senseless appointments into an art form, including those who have sat behind desks, represented them on boards, or have been allowed to wear a Tahs tracksuit.

Several Waratahs coaches have not been up to it. Quite a number were dominated by the players. Some backstabbed others. Two or three were simply not rated by the players. One in particular is still rated by many notable Test players as easily the worst coach they had ever encountered- and that is at any level of the game.

This coach was a genius in making moronic decisions. One notable moment during his excruciating reign occurred before a NSW training session when he decided to stage a "no-holds-barred behind-closed-doors" team meeting. The meeting had only been going a few minutes when the door burst open, and one of the Waratahs and Wallabies most decorated players, walked past me, shaking his head.

"I don't believe what I've just heard," the seething player exclaimed.

"This @#$%^&* idiot has told everyone in the room they'll get a start in a game this season, no matter what happens. I've had it. He's a joke. I'm outta here."

He stalked off to his car and went home. It didn't matter. He played the next game, and the next, and the ....

How poor the Waratahs have been is shown in the numbers. They boast an underwhelming 53.7 percent success rate in Super Rugby from 152 wins from 283 games. Only four of their nine Super Rugby coaches have a better than 50 percent record.

It might surprise some that Chris Hickey is at the top of the tree at 63.6 percent, followed by their only Super Rugby title-winning coach Michael Cheika (63.3), then McKenzie (56.1) and Bob Dwyer (55.9). Those under 50 are Hawkins and Kennedy (both 45.4), Williams (42.4) and Foley (25).

Gibson is also currently under 50. He has nine wins from 19 games for a 47.3 per cent victory rate.

But it's not just wins that matter. It's how a team plays. Whether they can entice the public. Attract a crowd. Make them believe they are something worthwhile.

Unfortunately under Gibson the Waratahs are nondescript. Really can anyone explain what the Waratahs are trying to do, and what exactly is the coach attempting to get them to do? What is their attacking strategy? Have they actually got a strategy? Is there a plan? Beats me.

There is not much logic in what they are doing, relying on individual moments rather than ensemble play to threaten. When their most consistent player is an under-the-radar hooker in Tolu Latu, primarily because he has willingly taken on the role of several other players who are not doing their bit, then you know a team is in serious trouble.

Moments of meaningless play this year abound. A case in point was the Sharks match in Durban. In the opening minutes, a high kick was aimed straight at Israel Folau. He took it, and had 45 metres of clear space. Here was the chance for Folau- supposedly the marquee player of Australian Rugby- to at last have a real go. Instead he threw a namby-pamby high pass to his captain Michael Hooper, who threw another namby-pamby pass to the fullback Andrew Kelleway, who went nowhere.

It was just going through the motions stuff, which is nothing new for Folau, who all year has failed to get out of first gear. To change that, it really requires a coach to show some authority. It really is time for Gibson to actually do something.

Admittedly the Waratahs haven't been helped by their chief playmaker Bernard Foley being sidelined.

But they have also been badly exposed by having no-one in reserve to properly direct them. So, the blame goes back onto the coaching staff for failing to ensure this position was adequately covered. Good coaching involves having every base covered- especially when there are injuries.

And then the players cruel themselves even further by making silly statements. Hooper was rightfully lampooned for saying at the end of a miserable appalling South African road trip: "It was a successful tour on the training paddock."

And No 8 Jed Holloway added to the stupidity a few days ago by uttering: "I know you guys gave Hoops plenty of s--- in the media about his comments, but we've been training really well."

Wow! The Waratahs playing ranks don't get it. It doesn't matter what you do on the training paddock. That's meaningless. It's whether you can deliver on match day that counts. And they wonder why they're currently running 16th.

It's really time for them to shut up and actually come up with something tangible in a Super Rugby match.

The Waratahs have a team song. One of the verses goes:

"We've got talent

We've got heart

We will tear your team apart

Playing the game as it should be played."

'Talent, heart, tearing teams apart, playing the game as it should be played'... the Waratahs players and staff are again having themselves on. If this continues, Gibson will be the one torn apart when he gets pushed through the exit door.