Whether it's against backup QBs or not, the Bills' defense is rolling

play
McAfee & Co. react to Bills' trade for Amani Hooker (1:33)

ORCHARD PARK, N.Y. -- The Buffalo Bills are executing something about as close to a midseason worst-to-first transformation as you'll ever see, albeit with a massive caveat.

Less than one month ago, the Bills trudged through their bye week with the NFL's 30th-ranked scoring defense and 31st-ranked total defense. So naturally in the weeks since, the Bills have allowed the fewest points and second fewest yards among the teams that have played three games.

It's been a steep turnaround for a Bills defense that's gone from the unit holding back the highest-scoring offense to a strength in its own right. But that turnaround has also coincided with the Bills playing almost exclusively against backup quarterbacks, a trend that'll continue when the Bills (8-1) host the Miami Dolphins (1-8) at Highmark Stadium on Sunday (1 p.m. ET, CBS).

So, as obvious as the answer might seem, it's worth asking the question: Is the game really that different when you're facing an NFL backup quarterback rather than a starter?

"It's definitely not the starters," Bills safety Amani Hooker told ESPN. "Nothing's easy. But it's just like anything else. The better talented guy is off the field in any position, it's not good for their team. I'm sure they feel the same way."

"I don't get to choose who I play. I just play," defensive lineman Ed Oliver adds. "Hell, who cares? If I got to choose who I could play, s---. I guess it would be a starter. But you don't get to choose. That's kind of how football works. People get hurt. Next man up."

Ask Bills players and coaches alike and they'll say there's real belief the defense is executing better regardless of the opposing quarterbacks. Defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard points to how the defense is steadily getting better at holding strong on second- and third-and-long.

Communication has improved in the secondary. Turnovers are up. Sacks are up. Third-down conversion rates are down. The defense is playing better in just about every way.

But again, it's tough to separate those improvements from the circumstances. Before the bye, the Bills played games against the likes of C.J. Stroud, Jared Goff, Drake Maye and Matthew Stafford.

Since, it's been games against rookie Joe Fagnano (after Lamar Jackson was injured on the Ravens' first offensive play and backup Tyler Huntley went out early in the second quarter) and Carson Wentz -- two quarterbacks who've since been replaced by trade acquisitions. Then it was rookie Cade Klubnik (for about half of the game with Geno Smith going out) making his NFL debut, with Kyle McCord, who also made his debut last week, up next.

"Just like anything in this profession, you can make a reason or an excuse and try to point to, well, we're only having success because of this," Bills coach Joe Brady says. "Our job is to go out there and play to our capabilities and to our standard, regardless of who's on the other side of the football.

"I think [our defense is] playing at a high level right now and they have a lot of trust in one another and the communication is at a high level. That's correlating to the success regardless of who's on the other side of the ball."

In a situation like this one where it's so tough to separate the chicken from the egg, it's helpful to look to an outsider. That's where Hooker comes in. Barely a week into his Bills tenure following his Nov. 10 trade from the Tennessee Titans, Hooker says he didn't have the luxury of time to diagnose what's working and not working for the Bills' defense before being thrust into the starting lineup. He's heard a couple of stray coaching points about areas where the team had been struggling.

Otherwise, anything he's observed has come from the perspective of an eight-year veteran figuring things out in real time.

"It really just [feels like] no matter what's going on we always feel like we're in the game," Hooker said. "There's really no panic, which I'm not used to. In Tennessee, it's 'The defense has to win the game' in order for us to win. That was the feel. Here, it's really just no panic. We've got Josh Allen on the other side. We just do our job and communicate, tackle, no big plays, we probably have a good chance of winning."

That, fundamentally, is the one thing that hasn't changed pre-bye to post-bye. The Bills have the best record in the AFC to go along with the second best strength of victory in the AFC. They were beating good quarterbacks despite the defense's struggles in September and October, and they've been beating bad quarterbacks with good defensive play in November.

"Fortunately or unfortunately, we've injured some quarterbacks in the [last three weeks] to where things have changed really fast within the game," Leonhard says. "To me, put on the tape, and are our guys executing? Is it clean football? Is it physical football? Are we stopping the run? Are we forcing teams into advantageous situations for us? I think we've been doing that."