It's finally here! Opening Day of the 2018 MLB season is upon us. Before you lock in your lineups and get ready to watch at-bats that actually count, here are a few fantasy thoughts to consider:
• Managers tend to be loyal to a fault when it comes to closers, which is why veteran relievers with a long history in the role tend to stay there. However, that's only true when that history is a shared one between closer and manager. So, in Cleveland, where Cody Allen has saved at least 30 games for the last three seasons, it would take a lot for Terry Francona to make a change. However, in situations where either the named closer is new (Brad Boxberger, Arizona) or it's the manager who has only recently grabbed the reins (Dave Martinez, Washington or Mickey Callaway, Mets), there's no equity built up over past shared successes. If relievers in situations like those of Boxberger or Sean Doolittle or Jeurys Familia look shaky at all over the first weekend of the season, I'd be quick to grab the next guy in line and stash them away.
• Don't fall victim to "Tuffy Rhodes Syndrome" -- the Opening Day version of recency bias. In 1994, Rhodes led off for the Chicago Cubs and promptly hit three home runs in his first three at-bats, all against Dwight Gooden. I realize many current fantasy managers may not even have been on the planet when that happened, let alone playing the game, but trust me when I say that there was a bit of a rush to grab Rhodes immediately after that effort. (Although to make that claim, you likely had to pick up a landline, with a rotary dial, and hope your league's commissioner picked up so he could record the move by hand and then fax the rest of the league to let them know.) Suffice to say, that was the pinnacle of Rhodes' career and he never again had any fantasy relevance whatsoever. So, if Jon Jay goes 4-for-4 leading off for the Royals on Thursday, or even hits a few home runs, don't forget he's still the same Jon Jay who went undrafted in most leagues. It would be a mistake to make a knee-jerk move like cutting Byron Buxton for Jay, should the Twins outfielder go 0-for-8 to start the season with six strikeouts. Give the season a little time to develop before making moves.
• That said, remember that managers are people, too, and very much subject to succumbing to the philosophies of "What have you done for me lately?" and "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." In terms of position battles that didn't quite play out all the way before the teams left their grapefruits and cacti behind, if the hitter who gets the first crack at a position goes 3-for-3 on Opening Day, or perhaps drives in the winning run on a walk-off single, he's very likely to be back in the lineup the following day -- and again and again until he cools off. On the flip side, if a potential platoon player goes 0-for-3 and grounds into two rally-killing double plays, don't be surprised to see "the other guy" taking his turn in the batter's box on Friday. Be prepared to adjust your daily lineups accordingly.
