Never mind Sandpapergate, cricket needs to set clear boundaries for ball management

A worker uses lemon juice to shine a cricket ball in Jalandhar Getty Images

Over the past fortnight, people have asked me so many times which side I'm on that I've lost count. I've already said elsewhere what I think of Usman Khawaja's courage. I'm not going to referee the rest because I think it's the wrong fight. What worries me is that it's dividing people who love the same game, and I fear it will open chasms inside a team that has to take the field together. The bickering has to stop.

Pat Cummins' news conference in Sydney was interesting. He announced it himself and took questions for more than an hour, with no statement to hide behind. He said he didn't know that sandpaper was going onto the field, and that Khawaja was wrong to say otherwise.

Khawaja has earned a hearing too. He says that after the Cape Town Test in 2018, he urged the group to take collective responsibility rather than leave the blame with Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft, and Cummins says he has no recollection of that. ​​Mitchell Starc stands by the joint statement the four bowlers issued in 2021, and Warner backs Khawaja. Nobody outside that room can settle it, and I don't intend to add to the argument.

What I want to talk about goes back much further. The first well-known dispute over the ball's condition arose in January 1977, when people accused England's John Lever of rubbing Vaseline on it during a Test in Madras. Officials did not bring any charges.

The game has argued about ball-tampering ever since without properly settling it.

Officials did not suspend any player for it until 2000. Before March 2018, there were plenty of controversies, and only a few brought the perpetrators any penalty. Tampering was a level-two offence, grouped with things like time-wasting, and the most a player could get for it was a one-Test ban or two ODIs. Faf du Plessis was fined half his match fee in 2013 and his full match fee in Hobart in 2016, and spent a lot of time asking the ICC to spell out what was actually allowed when it came to altering the condition of the ball. That's no criticism of him. His case just shows how vague and light the system was.

Meanwhile, ball management was practised and understood everywhere. Every fielding side "looked after" the ball, wink, wink, nudge, nudge, and everyone knew some teams pushed the edge. There was an unwritten code of the era that you didn't report a rival, and nobody did. Players have since admitted what their sides did in memoirs and interviews, years after the events, and nobody was charged.

I don't think players and coaches carry it alone. The ICC and the game's administrators own a real share of the responsibility. By treating the early episodes trivially, they made something like Cape Town far more likely. They had the better part of half a century to decide what was allowed and what the penalty should be, and mostly they didn't.

None of that excuses what happened in Cape Town. A premeditated plan, an abrasive object, an attempt to hide it, and then an explanation that didn't hold up were a distinct thing from a mint, and the three men involved have never pretended otherwise.

The ICC's own sanction was a fine for all three and a one-Test ban for Smith, with none for Warner, yet Cricket Australia imposed 12-month bans on Smith and Warner. As someone who's been remembered for one afternoon myself, I know how heavy that can be. They broke the rules and said so. Who else knew what is a separate question, and one I can't answer. My point is about the surrounding game. Decades of soft penalties and vague rules made a moment like this likely, and the consequences fell on three men.

Here's what I'd like to see.

The principals should sit down privately, away from the cameras and with someone both sides trust. They needn't agree on every detail. They do need to hear each other, and that can't happen through a microphone. Former players and commentators, myself included, should stop picking sides. Every time one of us lines up behind a former team-mate against a current member of the side, the gap widens. The other players involved have largely stayed quiet, and I hope they are left to speak in their own time.

The ICC should give players clearer guidance on what they may and may not do to the ball, so "ball management" stops depending on who's interpreting it. It should also set a clear scale of penalties that every national board follows, so a sanction doesn't depend on which board is in the spotlight. Cricket Australia and the ICC should say openly what they have learned from 2018 and what they have changed. And every team needs a way for an inexperienced player to raise a worry without it costing him his place.

Some of that has already happened. The ICC has made tampering a level-three offence, with bans of up to six Tests or 12 ODIs. Umpires seem to watch more closely, and captains know it will be dealt with more strictly. I've seen far less of the ball getting artificial help than I used to. That tells me something has changed, and it's a start.

If we do the rest, something worthwhile will have come out of Newlands. If we don't, we'll be back here before long, with another set of young players carrying it.