Bieber (4-3) had fanned at least eight in 20 straight games, but the reigning AL Cy Young Award winner fell short with seven. He was pulled after issuing his fourth walk, and finished his shortest outing of the season at 4 2/3 innings trailing 3-0.
“The last few outings haven't been super sharp like the beginning of the year,” Bieber said. “That's the way baseball goes if you're starting. You have to ride the highs and lows.”
The victory was Seattle’s third straight following a season-high five-game losing streak. Cleveland has lost three in a row.
Kendall Gravemen worked the ninth for his fifth save. The bullpen start was necessary after four Mariners with starts this season have landed on the injured list.
“They know they have to lean on each other,” Servais said.
Haniger, tied for the major league lead with 12 home runs, doubled and scored on Kyle Lewis’ single in the first.
Bieber walked Haniger and Kyle Seager to start the third, setting up J.P. Crawford’s two-run single. Crawford said the team decided to be aggressive against Bieber.
“Bring it on, I'm going to rake your face,” Crawford said. “That's what I'm thinking in the box.”
Bieber walked Lewis and Crawford to load the bases with two outs in the fifth, ending his appearance. Reliever Phil Maton got out of the jam with a strikeout.
“We certainly respect their starter and what he's done, but we were ready,” Mariners manager Scott Servais said.
Bieber leads the majors with 92 strikeouts after starting the season with 10 or more in his first four outings, another major league record.
The Indians scored twice in the sixth with help from third baseman Donovan Walton’s error that allowed José Ramírez to reach base. The Mariners turned a double play to get out of a bases-loaded jam in the seventh.
While Bieber’s string of games with eight-plus strikeouts came to an end, another continues. The pitcher moved into a tie for second with former Mariners pitcher Randy Johnson for the most consecutive games with at least seven strikeouts at 22. He’s got a ways to go to catch Johnson, who sits in first place with a separate string of 34 straight games with seven or more.
The last time Bieber didn’t strike out at least eight in a regular-season game was his final start of the 2019 season. He also struck out seven last year in a playoff start against the Yankees.
Crawford's two-run single with the bases loaded continued a trend for the Gold Glove shortstop. He now has 19 RBI in 20 career plate appearances with the bases loaded. He's batting .438 in those situations.
Mariners: RHP Keynan Middleton (right biceps strain) could return from the injured list soon, manager Scott Servais said. He’s scheduled to throw a bullpen session Monday to fellow injured Mariners LF Jake Fraley (left hamstring strain). Fraley’s next step is a rehabilitation assignment. Servais also said LHP Marco Gonzales will throw off a mound on Monday for the first time since straining his left forearm.
Mariners: LHP Yusei Kikuchi (1-2, 4.30) takes the mound in Seattle in the series opener against Detroit. He struck out a career-high 11 in his last outing, a no-decision against the Los Angeles Dodgers.
Why the union is fighting for MLB's middle-class free agents
Buster Olney, Tim Kurkjian and Doug Glanville discuss the market for middle-class MLB players and what the union is looking for in labor talks.
'It's going to get ugly for those guys': How the lockout could hurt MLB's midtier free agents
Not all players make eight or nine figures. For hundreds of veterans, their paychecks have been getting slashed -- and this winter, it might only get worse.
Everything you need to know about MLB's lockout
Will baseball's labor strife delay the 2022 season? We've got answers to all your questions after baseball's first work stoppage in 26 years.
2021-22 MLB free agency, offseason trade news and hot stove updates
Who are some of the top free agents for 2022? Which teams are looking to make big trades? We've got everything you need to know about the hot stove season.
How the lockout will impact baseball
The Baseball Tonight crew discusses how MLB will be impacted by the first lockout since 1994.
Will Chris Taylor move from a utility player to a starter for the Dodgers?
Buster Olney explains the Dodgers' plans for Chris Taylor after signing him to a four-year contract extension.