Oliver Bjorkstrand tipped in a goal from the doorstep to tie the game for Columbus with 16 seconds left in regulation.
“It was a very tough game overall for us,” Niederreiter said. “We didn’t play the way we wanted to play, but we found a way to win.”
The Hurricanes are 2-1-2 in their last five, following an eight-game win streak, and are in second place behind Tampa Bay in the Central Division.
Carolina dropped the first two to Columbus, one in overtime and one in a shootout, before winning both this week.
“They were definitely grind games, every single one of them," Niederreiter said. "We expect to win every one of them, but these last two were big ones.”
After a scoreless first, a Blue Jackets' second-period push finally paid off when Werenski fielded a rebounded puck off the back boards and bounced it in off Nedeljkovic's back at 7:03. The lead lasted only 46 seconds, until Paquette spun around in traffic and scored from the slot.
Necas gave Carolina a 2-1 lead late in the second when he poked a wrap-around shot in off Korpisalo's skate.
Columbus tied the game again early in the third when Atkinson's shot from the far left was inadvertently redirected by Carolina defenseman Dougie Hamilton. Niederreiter scored at 15:42 to put the Hurricanes up again, and Warren Foegele just missed an empty-netter with under a minute left before Bjorkstrand's goal sent to the game to overtime.
“We find a way to get one (point)," Werenski said, “There’s no time to sit here and feel sorry for ourselves that we didn’t get a second. I thought we played a good hockey game. There’s a lot of things we can take from that game and build on and there’s still some things we have to clean up.”
Columbus coach John Tortorella said the second and third periods were two of the best his team has played all year.
“That’s a big point for us,” he said. “Four games against one of the top teams in the league — we go 2-1-1 against them.”
With an assist on Niederreriter's goal, Hamilton has registered a point in the Hurricanes' last 13 games, tying the longest point streak in the NHL this season. Toronto's Auston Matthews had a 13-game scoring streak that stretched from mid-January to mid-February. It's also the longest point streak by a defenseman in franchise history.
NOW OR NEVER
The Blue Jackets are embarking on a stretch of games seen as important to their future. Starting the day just two points behind Chicago for the fourth playoff spot, they play eight of the next 10 against the leaders of the Central Division. Their performance could determine how active they’ll be at the NHL trade deadline April 12. Captain Nick Foligno and stalwart defenseman David Savard are among those who will be unrestricted free agents after the season, and they’ll likely draw some interest.
“We know that we are on the right track here, we really are," Foligno said.
Hurricanes: Host Tampa Bay on Saturday before departing for a two-game trip to Chicago.
Blue Jackets: Open a two-game series at Detroit on Saturday, the start of a six-game trip.
Follow Mitch Stacy at http://twitter.com/mitchstacy