Questions about volleyball coach's past prompt his removal amid review

The AAU, the largest youth-sports group in the nation, has announced a sweeping review of its child-protection policies amid scrutiny about whether it has ignored reforms put in place in the four years since sexual-abuse allegations were made against its former president.

The review came after Outside the Lines sought to question Amateur Athletic Union leadership about the group's affiliation with Rick Butler, a prominent and successful volleyball coach. Butler had been banned for life from coaching girls by a different national organization in 1995 after an ethics panel found he had had sexual relationships with three underage players several years prior.

The AAU's announcement, which was placed in the middle of an emailed newsletter to its 670,000 members and was signed by its president, Roger Goudy, also announced that Butler would "step aside from his volunteer administrative activities at AAU." The reason, it said, was to allow for "an independent review of our practices and procedures throughout the organization, especially those that relate to our youth."

Goudy's email on Thursday did not address what prompted the review, who would complete it or why Butler, who has been affiliated with the AAU since 1981, was stepping aside. It came hours after Outside the Lines had requested to interview Goudy about Butler, whose name was later removed from a list of district sports directors on the AAU's website.

Butler is considered by many to be the most powerful coach in the sport of youth volleyball. His Chicago-based club, Sports Performance, routinely turns out college-scholarship-level players and has a waiting list for its elite-level camps. In June, Butler coached his 18-and-under girls' team to a third straight national title at the AAU's open championships, a tournament played at the ESPN Wide World of Sports complex in Orlando, Florida.

But the 60-year-old has not entirely been able to distance himself from the allegations of three women who accused him of seducing them while he was a coach in his mid-20s; two said they were 16 at the time of the relationships and one 17. Various media reports over the past two decades have detailed the allegations, and even a simple Google query of Butler's name and "volleyball" produces the allegations associated with him.

Although the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services investigated and found "credible evidence" the allegations in 1995 were true, Butler never faced criminal charges. In its August 1995 decision banning Butler from coaching girls for life, a USA Volleyball ethics panel rejected Butler's denials and ruled that his conduct constituted "immorality, lack of judgment and unacceptable behavior." Butler sued, but an Illinois appellate court upheld the original decision in 1996.

He insisted in the hearing that all three women were 18 and the sex had been consensual: "The accusers have literally conspired to ruin my life and business," he said then. Butler declined comment last week to Outside the Lines.

On Monday, his attorney issued a statement on his behalf: "Mr. Rick Butler is a highly-respected and talented professional, happily married for 21 years and a father of one, whom has dedicated his life to the sport of volleyball. ... Mr. Butler denies any wrongdoing or illegal activity, nor has he ever been disciplined with the AAU or charged. Mr. Butler legally adopted his son in 1996 after an exhaustive background check and investigation were conducted with the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services, which is required by Illinois adoption law, (notably after allegations were made in 1994 regarding alleged behavior in the early to mid-1980s)."

In an interview with Outside the Lines, one of the women, Sarah Powers-Barnhard, publicly described for the first time what happened to her: "I felt I was special to Rick. I thought I was rare," said the 50-year-old, who runs her own club in Jacksonville, Florida. "I don't think we ever talked about it being wrong. But it was very clear it was, because my dad didn't know. My mom didn't know. ... It was a full sexual relationship with him."

Butler, whose volleyball practices are legendary for their intensity, never stopped fighting to remain affiliated with volleyball. USA Volleyball allowed him to reapply for admittance after five years, and he did so in 2000, earning a conditional membership that let him work as an administrator but not a coach.

In 2006, Butler helped form a league called the Junior Volleyball Association. As a rival to the U.S. Olympic-affiliated USA Volleyball, the JVA was an instant hit. Its low entry fees and easy access were popular with local clubs, and in a few short years, it had tens of thousands of members.

The JVA's influence grew even more when it struck a partnership in 2010 that made the AAU's championship the JVA's official end-of-year event. The moves swelled the AAU's membership with new players who made volleyball the organization's second-biggest sport -- behind boys' basketball.

The marriage with the AAU, however, was taking place just as that organization's leader began facing his own sexual-abuse allegations.

In 2011, Outside the Lines reported that two men said then-AAU president Bobby Dodd had molested them while they were teens under his care as a basketball coach in Memphis. Although Dodd never faced criminal charges, he was placed on leave. And the disclosures in the Outside the Lines story spurred the creation of two task forces that were charged with improving ways to police the AAU's 100,000 coaches and volunteers.

One recommendation in the 2012 task force report states, "A determination of ineligibility to have access to youth by another" group that serves youths "is sufficient grounds to render the person ineligible to participate in the AAU."

Lauren Book, a Florida-based child-protection advocate who helped to write that rule, believes it should have been used to remove Butler from any AAU affiliation. "We put our name on a document that said, 'Things are going to change here,'" she told Outside the Lines in an interview last month. "We didn't give the AAU a get-out-of-jail-free card."

Ron Book, Lauren's father and a Florida attorney, said that the two tried to engage Goudy, the AAU's president.

"We have been met with stonewalling," he said. "It's inconceivable, irresponsible and reprehensible. There is absolutely no reason why the AAU should have this man in contact with children."

On Monday, the Junior Volleyball Association issued a statement to its members saying that it is "against all forms of abuse of players" and that it "respects the processes that have been put in place by USAV and AAU to protect the privacy and rights of all involved in disputes over conduct."

In 2012, Butler received the AAU's Emil Breitkreutz Leadership Award, which, according to a news release, is a "prestigious honor ... awarded to the individual who shows outstanding leadership and dedication to AAU Volleyball."

Henry Forrest, president of the AAU until last year, said that he first learned about Butler's 1995 ethics case last summer, when a rival coach complained about Butler's rising role in the AAU.

Forrest said he tried to invite one of Butler's accusers to testify before the AAU's National Board of Review, which regulates membership, but was rejected. "I got an opinion from the chairman that it was outside the scope of my authority," he told Outside the Lines. "I was floored."

He lost the AAU's presidency to Goudy in an election last fall.

Forrest has even called on the U.S. Olympic Committee to become involved. In a June 15 letter, he asked it to investigate both the AAU and its own USA Volleyball, which recertified Butler again as recently as October 2014. He said he has not yet received a response.

In his brief email exchanges with Outside the Lines declining comment, Butler blamed the current furor on political infighting within AAU: "It's certainly not because I have been coaching at the AAU National Championship. Because I have been doing that since 1981."

For Powers-Barnhard, it has been hard watching Butler continue to coach teenage girls.

"That whole situation, why it happened, it's affected my whole life," she said. "It started me down a course, and there is a script for who I was. So I needed to get clarity and work on being healthy. Because that is not a normal, healthy way to start your teenage years, or have your first sexual experience.

"I don't like to relive it. But if I can help any other athlete -- any girl, any boy -- with a coach that has an intention to do something inappropriate, then I want to do that."

Producer Michael Sciallo of ESPN's Enterprise/Investigative Unit contributed to this report.